the topic whcih have written by Mr Andishmand is general idea which has discussed commonly by the th e afghan statemen , if we want to reaaly know the effect of such dialogu we must be alettle pateint bec the deplomacy process anong with the peace process either that success or not it is an step and we should not ignore the power of suadi arabia in this regard as thy had created the Taliban they c an also remove and also the govt of U.S have more trust and confidence over the the suadi king still than the afghan govt so karzai as an agent enter into the negociations not as a head of the state.